Expert Commentary: Thomas Hyland Robertson, DC 3/25/2009

Posted by Admin on March 25, 2010

Imagine a complicated pulley setup with rubber shock-absorbers between the parts and ropes moving through the system. What if you left this pulley out in the weather for 30 years, with minimal maintenance or lubrication? Rust and grit would probably start to restrict the movement of the parts, and the rubber might get brittle. The ropes could even tighten up and jam the pulley's motion.

Now imagine the complex knee joint as this pulley system, with its multiple ligament anchors, meniscus shock-absorbers, and cartilage-lined hinge; the long muscles of the leg are the ropes that move the system. Osteoarthritis (OA) is the rust and grit; lack of exercise and stretching, as well as poor diet, constitute the minimal maintenance.

Our bodies have a tendency to heal themselves, but when our muscles stay too tight for too long, they create abnormal motion in every joint they’re attached to. Over time, these abnormalities increase wear and tear on the joint, including damage to the menisci or knee cartilage. The greater the wear and tear, the greater the tissue inflammation. Chronic inflammation leads to scar tissue formation, and calcification of this scar tissue in and around joints is what we call degenerative joint disease, OA, or bone spurs.

When specific injuries such as meniscus tears are added to the system, the degeneration speeds up, as shown by a recent study in Arthritis & Rheumatism. According to that study, meniscus damage will almost triple the chances of OA of the knee occurring in older adults. (However, other studies show that OA can lead to meniscus damage—a chicken-and-egg scenario.)

Most joint pain actually comes from the surrounding muscle tissue. When properly treated and regularly stretched (and stimulated through exercise), this muscle pain can be dramatically reduced and the motion of the knee can start to be retrained.

One of the most common reasons for abnormal muscle tension around the knee is excessive sitting. Sitting causes chronic tightness in the hamstrings, calves, and hip flexors, as well as weakness in other major muscle groups like the abdominals and gluteals. This leads to secondary tightness in the thigh muscles (quadriceps), the major mover of the knee. When both the hamstrings on the back and quadriceps on the front are tight, the knee joint has more pressure on it, creating additional wear. Factor in 20 years of desk-sitting and driving, which tighten and weaken the muscular movers of the knee, and it’s easy to see why so many people in their 40s and 50s have knee problems.

Solutions? Take a break from seated postures every 15 minutes; stretch your hamstrings and calves at least three times a day (more often if you’ve been diagnosed with knee OA); and try yoga for whole-body stretching and strengthening. If you’ve had undiagnosed knee pain for more than a month, get an evaluation from a qualified health professional.

Other factors to consider:

  • Being overweight speeds up joint degeneration by increasing stress on all joints.
  • Foot and ankle problems can lead to unstable joints at every level above, namely the knee. (Picture the body as a house of cards—what happens when you knock down the bottom card, the foot?)
  • Chronic dehydration (from drinking too much caffeine and alcohol and too little water) can also affect the cartilage and menisci, which have a high water content.

Keep in mind that there’s no factory warranty for your knees: You have to provide the maintenance!

Thomas K. Hyland Robertson, DC

For more information, pleast click here.


Subscribe to our newsletter

Enter your email address to subscribe and receive notifications of new stories on

Featured Specialities:

Featured Doctors:

Optimal Wellness Network

Dr. Damon Noto, MD
Spine & Joint Pain Treatments

777 Terrace Avenue, 4th Floor
Hasbrouck Heights, NJ 07604

Call: 877-412-4838

Valley Spinal Decompression Center

Dr. Bruce Shannahoff, D.C.
Sciatica Pain Relief Glendale, California

5363 Balboa Blvd. Suite 430
Encino, CA 91316

Call: (888) 870-2099

Ferraro Spine & Rehabilitation

Dr. Peter Ferraro, D.C.
Pinched Nerve New Jersey

230 Midland Ave
Saddle Brook, NJ 07663

Call: 888-797-1692

 Associates in Family Chiropractic & Natural Health Care, P.C.
Back Pain Fairfield County

156 East Avenue
Norwalk, CT 06851

Call: (203) 838-1555

Keller Chiropractic

Dr. Melinda Keller, D.C.
Sciatica Doctor Crown Heights, Brooklyn, NY

372 Kingston Ave.
Crown Heights, NY 11213

Call: 888-871-4137

Empire Physical Medicine & Pain Management

Dr. Steven S. Moalemi, M.D.
Herniated Disc Treatment Uptown Manhattan, New York City

551 5th Avenue Ste. 525
New York, NY 10176

Call: (888) 898-7795

MedWell Spine & Neuropathy Center

 MedWell, L.L.C.
Physical Therapy in Bergen County, New Jersey

33 Central Ave
Midland Park, NJ 07432

Call: (888) 820-2250